Katie Sullivan
Mrs. Zurkowski
Honors 9- Yellows
20 September 2012
Abortion:
Rights
of the Unborn
Is it acceptable to kill an unborn child, just because
you don’t want it? The Supreme Court decision of Roe vs. Wade made abortion legal
up until late term pregnancy of about 20 weeks. The topic of abortion is much
debated and very controversial. On one the hand are those known as “pro-choice”
supporters, who believe that a woman should be able to have control of what
goes on in her body, and that abortion should be legal. On the other hand are
people known as “pro-life” supporters who believe that abortion is the murder
of unborn babies. No one denies that
homicide is immoral and illegal, but when it comes to abortion suddenly the
thought of murder is put on the back burner. A fetus in the womb is just as
human as any other person, yet it is legal to end its life with no second
thought. Fetuses are humans and deserve the right to life as much as any other
living creature. There are fetal homicide laws currently enacted, and there are
abortion alternatives available to women. Thus, abortion should be illegal at all
stages of pregnancy except in cases where the woman will die in result of the
birth or pregnancy.
What makes a human, human? A human breathes, has brain
activity, a beating heart, cells, and a response to stimuli. A fetus has
detectable brain waves at eight weeks. “Every abortion stops a heart that
begins beating 22 days after fertilization” (Balch). Every human has 46
chromosomes carrying genes that make each person unique. It is proven that from
the moment of conception, a fetus has these chromosomes (“Human Life”). “By 20
weeks, an unborn child reacts to being pierced by a needle with vigorous body
and breathing movements, moving away and showing an increase in stress and
hormones” (Balch). All of these proven
facts support that a fetus breathes, has brain activity, a beating heart, cells,
and a response to stimuli, all of the characteristics that every other human
has. However, despite the fact that a fetus is a human being, abortion is still
legal. Abortion is often seemingly acceptable because the fetus looks nothing
like a person, but isn’t it also true that a newborn baby looks nothing like a
teenager? So how can it be made justifiable to kill an unborn child just
because it doesn’t look the same as other humans? “A new born child does not
look like an adult person, but that does not make the child any less human” (“Human
Life”).
Assaulting or killing another person is a crime. It is
also an additional crime however to kill or injure a pregnant woman and her
unborn child. “In April 2004, President Bush (R) signed into law the Unborn
Victims of Violence Act, a bill that makes it a crime to injure or kill a fetus
during the commission of violent federal crime against a pregnant woman” (“Fetal
Homicide Laws”). This basically means
that if someone were to kill a pregnant woman, then that person would be
charged with two deaths, one for the mother and one for her unborn child. In
this sense a fetus is considered a person and is protected by law. “They say
that mothers who lose unborn children to violent crime should not have to
suffer the indignity of being told that their child is not recognized by law” (“Fetal
Homicide Laws”). This law is only enacted in twenty-nine states; hopefully it
will be eventually put into play in all fifty states (Fetal Homicide Laws). It’s
interesting that it is illegal to injure or kill a fetus in the womb, yet it is
legal to end a fetus’s life through abortion. The government’s position towards
abortion is hypocritical and contradictory. If it is illegal to injure or kill
a pregnant woman and her baby, then abortion should be illegal too, considering
it is doing the same thing. The other component of this law is the obvious
crime to kill a person. Abortion would be acceptable only in the case of when a
woman’s life is at stake. At that point, there are two humans on the line and
the mother’s life is just as important as the unborn child’s. In these
unfortunate situations the mother should have the right to an abortion since
her life is at a risk.
Abortion should be made illegal because there are always
abortion alternatives available. In the cases where a woman is not ready to
raise or child, or isn’t financially stable, there are other options to
abortion. They shouldn’t end an unborn child’s life for their own personal
reasons, or even because they think the baby will have a rough life with the
mother’s lack of money. “Mothers not wanting a baby because of a lack of money
should look at abortion alternatives like adoption” (Balch). Adoption is a
great alternative to abortion. The baby will be able to be adopted and grow up
in a stable environment and have the life that was destined for him/her. This
way the woman doesn’t have to get an abortion, and she doesn’t have to provide
for the child either. “For instance, the antiabortion group the National Right
to Life Committee (NRLC) says that there are nearly 3,000 Crisis Pregnancy
Centers in the U.S. Those centers advertise their willingness to provide
clothes and equipment for babies, as well as financial assistance and advice
for expectant mothers and information on adoption” (“Update: Abortion”). As this quote points out, there are many
places to get help during a pregnancy. If a woman wished to get an abortion
because she didn’t have enough money to raise a child, the Crisis Pregnancy
Centers provide financial aid and materials for babies to help the mother
(Update: Abortion). With these alternative options to abortion, there is no
need for abortion to be legal.
Some people believe that abortion should be legal, and
that women deserve the right to choose what goes on in their bodies. They don’t
think about what is going on in the body of the unborn child. Pro-choice
supporters compare the relationship of a set of human chromosomes and a human
to the blue prints and instructions that make up a building to the building
itself. They say that blueprints are made up of ink and paper, and are distinct
from the building itself (“Human Life”). This is wrong because a fetus is not
simply human chromosomes, it is a human being. Blueprints of a building would
be equivalent to the DNA of a person, which both adults and fetuses have. “At
that moment…the fetus is formed as a unique person that, if allowed to develop
freely, would grow to function independently” (“Human Life”). In this quote,
“that moment” is referring to the moment of conception, when a new human being
is created.
The solution to abortion would be to repeal the Roe v.
Wade law, and make abortion illegal. Currently, counseling has to be given to
the patient wishing to receive an abortion about the extent to which the fetus
can feel pain and the alleged and disputed link between abortions and breast
cancer (“Abortion: Update”). This is not
enough to stop women from undergoing abortions. NARAL acknowledged that
“Medicaid-eligible women in states that exclude abortion coverage have abortion
rates of about half of those women in states that fund abortion care,” so if
coverage for abortion is lacking, lives will be saved (“Balch”). This should be
enacted in all states if not making abortion illegal completely.
Abortion
is wrong and should be illegal except in the cases where the woman will die as
a result of the pregnancy or birth process. There
is really no need for abortion to be legal, because fetuses are human being
that should be treated with respect even though they can’t speak for
themselves. With fetal homicide laws in place, abortion should also be looked
at in the same way. There are abortion alternatives and financial help
available to pregnant women. Finally, people should know that getting pregnant
is a result of sex. If abortion was illegal, there would most likely be less
unprotected sex and sex in general. More people will fear getting pregnant and
not having abortion as an option to them. Abortion being made illegal will
ultimately lead to less STD’s. Hopefully
abortion will one day be illegal, making the world a safer place.
Jeremy Eagle
http://www.2facts.com/icof_story.aspx?PIN=i1000520&term=abortion
Works Cited
"Abortion: When Does Human Life Begin?" Issues
& Controversies. Facts On File News Services, 22 Aug. 2005. Web. 25
Sept. 2012.
Balch, Mary Spaulding. "Protect the Unborn." Sirs
Issues Reasearcher. USA Today, 22 Mar. 2011. Web. 25 Sept. 2012.
"Fetal Homicide Laws." Issues & Controversies.
Facts On File News Services, 25 June 2004. Web. 25 Sept. 2012.
<http://www.2facts.com/article/i0901360>.
"Infobase Learning - Login." Issues &
Controversies. Facts On File News Services, 23 July 2012. Web. 25 Sept.
2012. <http://www.2facts.com/article/i1700270>.
"Update: Abortion." Issues & Controversies.
Facts On File News Services, 22 Feb. 2011. Web. 25 Sept. 2012.